Top Theme Image
Top Theme Image

Carolyn & Lily

Saturday, May 2, 2026 • Kingston, NY

Carolyn & Lily

Saturday, May 2, 2026 • Kingston, NY
Gallery Photo 1
Gallery Photo 2
Gallery Photo 3
Gallery Photo 4
Gallery Photo 5
Gallery Photo 6

Lily and Carolyn’s story began the way many modern romances do: with a swipe on Bumble. At the time, Lily was living on Long Island and Carolyn in Harlem, which meant the first nine months of their relationship were spent heroically braving what they called “long distance” (read: the LIRR schedule and a couple of tolls). They spent the following year and a half traveling, seeing Broadway shows, and finding excuses to eat their way through new places. They’ve visited friends and family and explored destinations such as Spain, France, Maine, Michigan, Ohio, Massachusetts, North Carolina, Georgia, South Carolina, Upstate New York, and Colorado—making memories and collecting stories along the way.


Their engagement story is fitting for two people who love intention and romance. Carolyn proposed first, at a Long Island beach where they had one of their early dates, creating a full-circle moment. The next week, while traveling in Spain, Lily proposed in the bonsai garden at the Madrid Botanical Garden—because they needed two "yeses." Even Frieda (their bestest Parakeet) said "yes!" to her moms tying the knot.


When they’re not traveling, you can find Lily teaching golf at Five Iron or Carolyn managing events at The New York Times and wrangling spreadsheets at ArtsPool. They can’t wait to celebrate their wedding with all of you, and to see what adventures the future holds—ideally with plenty of Broadway tickets, a fluffy sidekick, and a few straight golf balls along the way.

A Bumble success story! Our story begins with Lily's opening message two days before her 29th birthday.

January 16, 2023

A Bumble success story! Our story begins with Lily's opening message two days before her 29th birthday.
Our first date was at Besito in Huntington, LI. Carolyn was out of the city house-sitting (thanks Em!) and Lily rushed over after team practice. We were joined by a cockroach that floated in Carolyn's water glass which broke the first date tension and made for many more laughs throughout the night. 
This photo is from our third date, in early March, this time in the city, where Lily came to visit the NY Times.

February 01, 2023

Our first date was at Besito in Huntington, LI. Carolyn was out of the city house-sitting (thanks Em!) and Lily rushed over after team practice. We were joined by a cockroach that floated in Carolyn's water glass which broke the first date tension and made for many more laughs throughout the night. This photo is from our third date, in early March, this time in the city, where Lily came to visit the NY Times.
Carolyn met Frieda. This was a big deal. (if you know you know)

March 01, 2023

Carolyn met Frieda. This was a big deal. (if you know you know)
Officially 'girlfriends', 'going steady', whatever the kids are saying these days! Walking through Central Park.

March 06, 2023

Officially 'girlfriends', 'going steady', whatever the kids are saying these days! Walking through Central Park.
An Italian woman and an Irish woman walk into a bar.....
First St. Patty's day!

March 17, 2023

An Italian woman and an Irish woman walk into a bar..... First St. Patty's day!
Meeting the Bartell's!

May 07, 2023

Meeting the Bartell's!
And some cousins!

May 21, 2023

And some cousins!
Moments where we have absolutely laughed the hardest -- Lily's AC falling out of the window.

June 01, 2023

Moments where we have absolutely laughed the hardest -- Lily's AC falling out of the window.
Our first adventure together -- Carolina Beach, NC! (Thanks Erin!)

June 06, 2023

Our first adventure together -- Carolina Beach, NC! (Thanks Erin!)
PRIDE 2023 -- lots of rainbow, lots of friends and lots of fun.

June 25, 2023

PRIDE 2023 -- lots of rainbow, lots of friends and lots of fun.
BIG fans of 'lake life'

July 29, 2023

BIG fans of 'lake life'
We moved in together in Astoria! To no ones surprise, Lily found us the perfect apartment to U-Haul it to! We've been in this spot for almost 3 years and it will always be the first place we made a home together.

September 01, 2023

We moved in together in Astoria! To no ones surprise, Lily found us the perfect apartment to U-Haul it to! We've been in this spot for almost 3 years and it will always be the first place we made a home together.
Throwback to the days when Lily ate gluten, and one of our favorite date nights at the Feast of San Gennaro.

October 01, 2023

Throwback to the days when Lily ate gluten, and one of our favorite date nights at the Feast of San Gennaro.
Date night meeting Coach Beard and hearing (our wedding band) Hello Brooklyn! And subsequently the first night that Carolyn threw up in front of Lily (if you know you know).

November 03, 2023

Date night meeting Coach Beard and hearing (our wedding band) Hello Brooklyn! And subsequently the first night that Carolyn threw up in front of Lily (if you know you know).
Our first holidays together! We raced home from a fun Thanksgiving in Minneapolis, to start decorating our apartment with all Christmas cheer. Lily then experienced her first big Italian Christmas (and lived to tell the tale).

December 25, 2023

Our first holidays together! We raced home from a fun Thanksgiving in Minneapolis, to start decorating our apartment with all Christmas cheer. Lily then experienced her first big Italian Christmas (and lived to tell the tale).
Birthday trip 2024 -- Rang in Lily's 30th birthday with a trip to the Dominican Republic. And a few days later, celebrated Carolyn's 32nd birthday back in NYC.

January 20, 2024

Birthday trip 2024 -- Rang in Lily's 30th birthday with a trip to the Dominican Republic. And a few days later, celebrated Carolyn's 32nd birthday back in NYC.
So many trips and visits with friends!

March 30, 2024

So many trips and visits with friends!
And more fun with friends!

May 18, 2024

And more fun with friends!
Summer of love in Paris, just a week before the Olympics kicked off! One of the most spectacular trips, made even better by meeting Heather!

July 03, 2024

Summer of love in Paris, just a week before the Olympics kicked off! One of the most spectacular trips, made even better by meeting Heather!
Adventuring through the French countryside, seeing the Olympic torch being carried and thinking 'Maybe we shouldn't go home?'

July 06, 2024

Adventuring through the French countryside, seeing the Olympic torch being carried and thinking 'Maybe we shouldn't go home?'
Our first foster pooch, Iris, formerly known as Essence, and now known as Summer. An identity crisis on four legs and sporting the cutest smile.

July 15, 2024

Our first foster pooch, Iris, formerly known as Essence, and now known as Summer. An identity crisis on four legs and sporting the cutest smile.
Lake life on Lake Charlevoix -- our first trip to 'the cottage'!

August 08, 2024

Lake life on Lake Charlevoix -- our first trip to 'the cottage'!
We have a tradition of 'Surprise date night' where every month we trade off who plans an unknown activity for date night. Over the years, we have done a lot of fun things, but this 'surprise date weekend' that Lily planned will never be topped. Lily booked a full weekend trip to Denver so we could see our favorite artist, Brandi Carlile, play at Red Rocks. We spent the morning hiking and then went to the most incredible concert we will ever experience. This photo is from our 'seats' for the concert, which was a crowded planter box along the edge of the venue, as we loved every minute.

September 07, 2024

We have a tradition of 'Surprise date night' where every month we trade off who plans an unknown activity for date night. Over the years, we have done a lot of fun things, but this 'surprise date weekend' that Lily planned will never be topped. Lily booked a full weekend trip to Denver so we could see our favorite artist, Brandi Carlile, play at Red Rocks. We spent the morning hiking and then went to the most incredible concert we will ever experience. This photo is from our 'seats' for the concert, which was a crowded planter box along the edge of the venue, as we loved every minute.
We've visited both of our alma maters over our relationship -- Go Orange! Go BG!

October 20, 2024

We've visited both of our alma maters over our relationship -- Go Orange! Go BG!
Halloween 2024 - A unicorn and her security guard

October 31, 2024

Halloween 2024 - A unicorn and her security guard
Second holidays together, this time combining our families for one big feast of the 'many' fishes.

December 24, 2024

Second holidays together, this time combining our families for one big feast of the 'many' fishes.
HHI Alumni -- first visit to Hilton Head Island, both the birth place and alma mater of the Lily Bartell.

February 04, 2025

HHI Alumni -- first visit to Hilton Head Island, both the birth place and alma mater of the Lily Bartell.
Since our move to Astoria, we've joined and hosted our LGBTQ+ bookclub, Queereads, run by our friends Jackie, Jamie and Katie. It has gotten both of us back into reading and the meetings are the highlight of every month!

July 18, 2025

Since our move to Astoria, we've joined and hosted our LGBTQ+ bookclub, Queereads, run by our friends Jackie, Jamie and Katie. It has gotten both of us back into reading and the meetings are the highlight of every month!
Over our relationship we have been to more women's sports games then we can count -- Gotham FC (soccer), Sirens PWHL (hockey) or Liberty (WNBA), we are big fans!

March 22, 2025

Over our relationship we have been to more women's sports games then we can count -- Gotham FC (soccer), Sirens PWHL (hockey) or Liberty (WNBA), we are big fans!
Easter 2025 -- 'The one where everyone thought Lily and Carolyn were getting engaged'

We hosted both of our families for a marathon weekend of eating and sightseeing. Lily was a supreme deviled egg maker and Carolyn tried her hand at homemade bread for the first time, meanwhile everyone had secret bets going of when we were getting engaged that weekend (ha!)

April 20, 2025

Easter 2025 -- 'The one where everyone thought Lily and Carolyn were getting engaged' We hosted both of our families for a marathon weekend of eating and sightseeing. Lily was a supreme deviled egg maker and Carolyn tried her hand at homemade bread for the first time, meanwhile everyone had secret bets going of when we were getting engaged that weekend (ha!)
Carolyn's Proposal -- So a little backstory. We had been designing rings together for months, so there was no surprise that we were on the 'engagement train'. When we went to pick up our rings, a week before our trip to Spain, unfortunately the designers had made Lily's ring incorrectly! Gasp! This was an even bigger issue because Carolyn had planned to propose before the trip! While the designer rushed to get us the corrected ring by the time we left for our trip, Carolyn decided to move forward with her special proposal, without the real ring and instead subbing in a ruby ring of hers from childhood. For the April surprise date night, Carolyn took Lily to the Eaton's Neck Beach on Long Island, where they had spent one of their first dates, and she collected memorable food, drink and momentos from their relationship for a proposal picnic/date night. We both cried a lot, Lily was very surprised, Carolyn was very relieved (and also very sick) and for a week Lily wore the ruby ring. This picture pretty much sums up our feelings at sunset that evening.

April 28, 2025

Carolyn's Proposal -- So a little backstory. We had been designing rings together for months, so there was no surprise that we were on the 'engagement train'. When we went to pick up our rings, a week before our trip to Spain, unfortunately the designers had made Lily's ring incorrectly! Gasp! This was an even bigger issue because Carolyn had planned to propose before the trip! While the designer rushed to get us the corrected ring by the time we left for our trip, Carolyn decided to move forward with her special proposal, without the real ring and instead subbing in a ruby ring of hers from childhood. For the April surprise date night, Carolyn took Lily to the Eaton's Neck Beach on Long Island, where they had spent one of their first dates, and she collected memorable food, drink and momentos from their relationship for a proposal picnic/date night. We both cried a lot, Lily was very surprised, Carolyn was very relieved (and also very sick) and for a week Lily wore the ruby ring. This picture pretty much sums up our feelings at sunset that evening.
Lily's Proposal -- Lily had been trying to find the right moment to pop the question during our entire time in Madrid, and unsurprisingly Carolyn kept ruining each attempt. On our last day in Madrid, towards the end of a beautiful stroll through the botanic gardens outside of the Prado Art Museum, Lily was finally able to propose! The moment and setting were perfect, in a tucked away corner of the bonsai tree collection, with the sun shining just after a rainstorm. Here we are pictured, post question-popping, with our bonsai tree.

May 05, 2025

Lily's Proposal -- Lily had been trying to find the right moment to pop the question during our entire time in Madrid, and unsurprisingly Carolyn kept ruining each attempt. On our last day in Madrid, towards the end of a beautiful stroll through the botanic gardens outside of the Prado Art Museum, Lily was finally able to propose! The moment and setting were perfect, in a tucked away corner of the bonsai tree collection, with the sun shining just after a rainstorm. Here we are pictured, post question-popping, with our bonsai tree.
Carolyn 're-proposes' following Lily's proposal in the bonsai gardens, with a letter she had been carrying around and (thankfully) the corrected ring! The note reads 'As per our last discussion, will you marry me? Thanks! Carolyn'

May 05, 2025

Carolyn 're-proposes' following Lily's proposal in the bonsai gardens, with a letter she had been carrying around and (thankfully) the corrected ring! The note reads 'As per our last discussion, will you marry me? Thanks! Carolyn'
Enjoying our Engagement-moon in the Spanish Canary Islands. Great food, mucho relaxation and we loved sporting our new bling.

May 08, 2025

Enjoying our Engagement-moon in the Spanish Canary Islands. Great food, mucho relaxation and we loved sporting our new bling.
We said YES to our venue, Senate Garage (less than 10 days after getting back from our engagement-moon!) We didn't need to look anywhere else, it captured our vibe and we could immediately envision our special day there. We can't wait to share it with you all!

May 21, 2025

We said YES to our venue, Senate Garage (less than 10 days after getting back from our engagement-moon!) We didn't need to look anywhere else, it captured our vibe and we could immediately envision our special day there. We can't wait to share it with you all!
Favorite moment of Summer 2025 -- Kayaking on Coffee Pond (thank you Thompson's!)

August 22, 2025

Favorite moment of Summer 2025 -- Kayaking on Coffee Pond (thank you Thompson's!)
Lily's first trip to Wildwood Crest, NJ! Carolyn refused to marry her until she went to the Jersey Shore, so it was time to cross that off the list.

August 30, 2025

Lily's first trip to Wildwood Crest, NJ! Carolyn refused to marry her until she went to the Jersey Shore, so it was time to cross that off the list.
Fall. Family. Football. 
Looking forward to many more shot-ski's and Maryland vs Nebraska rivalries with these two!
(Mike, will you hurry up and make Shelby our sister-in-law already?!)

October 13, 2025

Fall. Family. Football. Looking forward to many more shot-ski's and Maryland vs Nebraska rivalries with these two! (Mike, will you hurry up and make Shelby our sister-in-law already?!)
A night at the movies to see the Bruce Springsteen bio-pic with friends, started with lots of celebrating thanks to the most over zealous PF Changs waiter there ever was. (Thanks Tom!) 
Photo taken by our fabulous friend, resident young person, (the Rev.) David Meyers, who will be officiating our wedding!

October 24, 2025

A night at the movies to see the Bruce Springsteen bio-pic with friends, started with lots of celebrating thanks to the most over zealous PF Changs waiter there ever was. (Thanks Tom!) Photo taken by our fabulous friend, resident young person, (the Rev.) David Meyers, who will be officiating our wedding!
Halloween 2025: Just a coupla' crazy crayons!

October 31, 2025

Halloween 2025: Just a coupla' crazy crayons!
Rang in our wedding year with friends in California! (Congrats Erin & Zach!)

January 01, 2026

Rang in our wedding year with friends in California! (Congrats Erin & Zach!)